AeroGarden vs. Click & Grow: Which Countertop Garden Should You Buy?

#1 Pick

AeroGarden Harvest Indoor Hydroponic Garden

Runner-up

AeroGarden Bounty Elite Indoor Garden

Best Budget

Click and Grow Smart Garden 9

Updated November 2026. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

This guide is based on manufacturer specifications and published sources, not a hands-on test of every system in our garden. Where a figure comes from a company, we say so.

Quick Answer: AeroGarden or Click & Grow?

Choose an AeroGarden if you want a true hydroponic garden: roots in a nutrient solution, liquid plant food you add to the tank, and a pumped water bowl. The Harvest is the simple six-pod starter, with a 20-watt light and a 10.5-by-6-inch footprint. The Bounty Elite is the step up: nine pods, a 50-watt adjustable light, a touchscreen, vacation mode, and Wi-Fi plus Alexa.

Choose the Click & Grow Smart Garden 9 if you want the lowest-maintenance countertop garden and you do not need a hydroponic tank. Click & Grow uses Smart Soil pods and a wick. There is no pump noise and no liquid fertilizer to mix. It uses 13 watts and, per the company, 6.2 kilowatt-hours a month. You are buying into that pod system, and you will not get the same “roots in the water” growing style as an AeroGarden.

Shoppers often treat these as the two default indoor gardens, but they do not work the same way. Click & Grow’s own comparison with AeroGarden calls out that difference: capillary precision irrigation versus hydroponics. This page stays with official specifications and that distinction. For a wider field that includes towers, see the best hydroponic indoor gardens guide and the indoor hydroponics hub.

The Difference That Matters: Water and Nutrients

An AeroGarden is a compact deep-water-style hydroponic system. Plants sit in a deck above a water bowl. Roots grow into the tank. You add liquid plant food on a schedule, and a pump keeps the solution moving. AeroGarden’s Harvest listing describes a control panel that reminds you when to add water and nutrients. When a crop is finished, you clean the tank, because roots and film build up in the water. Click & Grow’s comparison notes that roots in an AeroGarden can tangle in the reservoir, which is why many owners start and replace a full set of plants together.

A Click & Grow Smart Garden waters a pod, not a shared nutrient tank. Each plant sits in Smart Soil. A wick reaches down into a reservoir of plain water and uses capillary action to keep the pod moist. Nutrients are already in the soil-like medium and are released over time, so you do not dose the tank. The company says the roots stay in the pod, which makes it easier to pull one plant and put another in its place without disturbing the rest. The garden is silent because there is no pump.

That is why Click & Grow markets the system as “easier than hydroponics,” and why this page does not call the Smart Garden 9 a hydroponic kit. It is still a capable indoor garden with a grow light. It is just a different tool.

Spec Comparison

Harvest and Bounty Elite figures come from AeroGarden’s listings and official model notes. Smart Garden 9 figures come from Click & Grow’s specification sheet and product page. Energy costs below use the EIA average residential rate of 18.19 cents per kilowatt-hour for 2026 year-to-date through August, and they are labeled as calculations where we had to assume a daily run time.

AeroGarden HarvestAeroGarden Bounty EliteClick & Grow Smart Garden 9
MethodHydroponic water bowlHydroponic water bowlSmart Soil + wick (not hydroponic)
Plant sites6, up to 12″ tall99
Light20W LED, automatic timer50W adjustable LEDLED, 13W
EnergyNot published as kWh/month. Example: 20W × 15 hours/day ≈ 9 kWh, about $1.64Not published as kWh/month. Example: 50W × 15 hours/day ≈ 22.5 kWh, about $4.096.2 kWh/month, about $1.13 (official monthly figure)
TankWater bowl (exact gallons not listed on the Harvest page we used)Larger bowl than the Harvest, per the Elite listing4 liters (1.06 gal); up to ~3 weeks, up to 6 liters of water/month
Size10.5″ L × 6″ W × 17.4″ H; 5.2 lbStainless deck; Bounty family grow height up to 24″23.6″ × 7.5″ × 15.8″ with one extension; 5.3 lb
ControlsIlluminated buttons, remindersTouchscreen, app, Alexa, vacation modePlug in; optional app for plant-care tips
NutrientsLiquid plant food, 3 oz includedLiquid plant food, reminders on the screenBuilt into each pod; no tank fertilizer
NoisePumpPumpSilent (no pump)
Replacing one plantRoots share the tank; a mid-cycle swap is messierSame shared-tank issue, more plantsSwap one cup without disturbing the others

AeroGarden Harvest: The Simple Hydroponic Starter

1. AeroGarden Harvest

Best simple hydroponic starter

AeroGarden Harvest indoor hydroponic garden
  • Plant sites: 6 pods, plants up to 12 inches tall
  • Size / weight: 10.5″ L × 6″ W × 17.4″ H; 5.2 lb
  • Lights: 20W full-spectrum LED with automatic timer
  • Included: Seed pod kit, 3 oz liquid plant food, power adapter

The Harvest is the least you can buy and still get a real hydroponic loop: water, nutrients, pump, and a timed light. It is compact enough for a narrow strip of counter. It does not need Wi-Fi. The 12-inch height cap is the constraint to take seriously. Herbs and loose-leaf lettuce fit. A compact tomato does not.

AeroGarden’s “up to 5x faster than in soil” germination claim is the company’s, not an independent test. Take it as marketing for a well-lit, well-watered pod, not as a number to plan a harvest calendar around.

Pros

  • True hydroponic system at a starter size
  • No app or account required
  • Small footprint

Cons

  • Only six plants and 12 inches of height
  • You mix liquid nutrients and clean the tank
  • The pump is not silent

AeroGarden Bounty Elite: More Light, Height, and Controls

2. AeroGarden Bounty Elite

Best AeroGarden when you want more light

AeroGarden Bounty Elite indoor garden
  • Plant sites: 9
  • Lights: 50W adjustable LED (Elite; Basic is 30W, standard Bounty is 40W, per AeroGarden)
  • Controls: Full-color touchscreen, automatic timer, water and plant-food reminders
  • Connected features: Wi-Fi, Alexa, AeroGarden app, vacation mode
  • Build: Stainless steel, larger bowl and deck than the Harvest

The Elite is the Harvest idea with the limitations turned up: more pods, a much stronger lamp, and the 24-inch grow height of the Bounty family, which is what you need if you are determined to try compact tomatoes or peppers on a counter. Vacation mode is the feature that matters if you travel. The Wi-Fi and Alexa layer is useful if you like that kind of control, and ignorable if you do not, so long as you still use the on-unit screen.

It is still a nine-plant countertop garden. If your complaint with the Harvest is “I want a family salad supply,” skip the Elite and look at a vertical tower instead.

Pros

  • 50W adjustable light and nine pods
  • Vacation mode and a taller grow height
  • Reminders and app or Alexa control

Cons

  • Costs more and takes more counter space than the Harvest
  • Same shared-tank cleaning as any AeroGarden
  • Nine plants is not a 30-site tower

Click & Grow Smart Garden 9: The Low-Effort Alternative

3. Click & Grow Smart Garden 9

Best low-maintenance countertop garden

Click and Grow Smart Garden 9
  • Plant sites: 9
  • Lights / energy: 13W; 6.2 kWh/month, per Click & Grow (about $1.13 at the EIA average rate)
  • Tank: 4 liters (1.06 gal), enough for up to three weeks, per the company
  • Size / weight: 23.6″ × 7.5″ × 15.8″ with one extension; 5.3 lb
  • Method: Smart Soil pods, wick watering, no tank fertilizer

If your priority is “plug it in, add water, do almost nothing,” this is the stronger design. The official monthly energy figure is low, the tank is large enough to go a couple of weeks, and the company says monthly water use is up to about 6 liters (200 ounces). A starter kit includes three basil, three green lettuce, and three mini tomato pods, plus two lamp extensions and germination domes.

The limits are the flip side of that simplicity. You buy Click & Grow pods for the best results (or experimental seedless pods if you want to try your own seeds). You cannot tune a shared nutrient mix. And nine compact plants in Smart Soil will not match a pumped hydroponic system that is being run well with a strong light. The Amazon listing we verified, ASIN B0HHN83RS4 in green, is sold by Click and Grow (Official) and was in stock on November 16, 2026.

Pros

  • Silent, and no liquid fertilizer to measure
  • Very low official energy use
  • Easy to replace one plant at a time

Cons

  • Not a hydroponic nutrient system
  • You rely on the brand’s pods
  • Less flexibility for taller fruiting plants than a Bounty Elite

Which One Should You Buy?

Buy the Harvest if

You want to learn hydroponics without much money or space, you are happy with herbs and short greens, and you do not want an account, an app, or a pod brand to be the whole experience. You will have to add plant food and clean the bowl. That is the hobby.

Buy the Bounty Elite if

You already know you like the AeroGarden method and you want more light, more height, and a vacation setting. It is the right upgrade path inside the brand. It is the wrong upgrade path if what you actually need is 20 or 30 plants.

Buy the Smart Garden 9 if

You want the garden to be quiet and almost boring to own, you will buy the pods, and you are growing herbs and compact greens rather than trying to force a tomato into a premium appliance. The official 6.2 kilowatt-hour figure also makes it the cheapest of these three to power at typical U.S. rates.

What we would not do

We would not pick a winner on brand loyalty, and we would not call Click & Grow a hydroponic system. We would also not expect any of these to feed a family the way a 30-plant tower can. These are countertop gardens. They excel at flavor and convenience, not at replacing a farm stand.

A direct Click & Grow affiliate link (the company advertises 10% or more) would likely earn more than an Amazon Associates link. We have not joined that program. Until it is approved, the buttons on this page go to Amazon with our tag.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Click & Grow hydroponic?

No. Click & Grow describes the Smart Garden as a capillary wick system with Smart Soil. Water stays in the tank as plain water, and nutrients are in the pod. An AeroGarden is hydroponic: liquid fertilizer goes in the tank and roots grow into that solution.

Which is easier for a beginner?

Click & Grow is easier day to day because you do not mix nutrients or clean a root-filled tank as often, and it is silent. The Harvest is easier to understand as “a little hydroponic farm,” and it does not require you to stay in one pod ecosystem. Both are beginner-friendly in different ways.

Which uses less electricity?

The Smart Garden 9, based on published numbers: 6.2 kWh a month, or about $1.13 at the EIA average rate of 18.19 cents per kWh. AeroGarden does not publish a monthly kWh figure for the Harvest or Bounty Elite. A 20-watt lamp running 15 hours a day is about 9 kWh ($1.64); a 50-watt lamp on the same example is about 22.5 kWh ($4.09).

Can I use my own seeds in either system?

Yes, with limits. Click & Grow sells seedless experimental pods. AeroGarden and similar hydroponic decks can be used with compatible sponges or kits made for your own seeds. Compact varieties still have to fit the light height, especially on the Harvest’s 12-inch cap.

Which grows plants faster?

AeroGarden claims germination up to five times faster than soil, which is a company figure. In principle, a well-run hydroponic tank with a stronger light (especially the 50-watt Elite) can push leafy growth hard. Click & Grow emphasizes ease and a tuned pod, not maximum speed. We did not run a timed grow-off, so we will not invent a winner on days to harvest.

Related Guides

Leave a Comment